Time Clocks

Biometric vs Badge vs Mobile Time Clocks, Which Fits Your Team

Phone apps, badge clocks and biometric clocks side by side, matched to the conditions where your hourly team clocks in, with a clock for each work environment.

A person presses a fingertip to the blue sensor of a white WorkEasy fingerprint time clock on a concrete column, with warehouse shelving out of focus behind.
On this page
Back to Blog Home

Key takeaways

  • Match the clock to the conditions at the punch point, meaning the hands, the traffic, the installation and the connectivity, not to a ranking of clock types.
  • On its own, a phone app or a badge records whoever holds it. A fingerprint, facial or palm clock ties the punch to the worker.
  • With no wall or power at the punch point, or no wired network and no Wi-Fi there, look at the portable and mobile clocks, which run on battery and 4G LTE.
  • A badge clock is the fastest tap and a useful backup, and it confirms the card, not the person.
  • Different conditions can call for different clocks, while every WorkEasy clock reports into one system with one place for your pay rules.

A clock that works in the office can fail on the dock. Phones stay in lockers, a badge records whoever taps it, and the wrong fingerprint reader struggles with greasy hands.

A biometric time clock confirms who is clocking in by face, fingerprint or palm. A badge clock records whoever taps the card. A phone app on its own records whoever holds the phone. For hourly teams on shared sites, biometric clocks tie each punch to the real worker, and the right sensor depends on the conditions. Start with where your people work, because the clock that fits a clean office may not fit a loading dock or an open yard.

The three types of time clocks at a glance

The three types of time clock are phone apps, badge clocks and biometric clocks, and they differ on one question, which is what the punch proves. On its own, a phone app or a badge records whoever holds it. A biometric clock matches the worker. The table splits biometric clocks into fingerprint and facial, because their conditions differ.

Phone appBadge clockFingerprint clockFacial recognition clock
How it confirms the punchRecords whoever holds the phoneRecords whoever taps the cardMatches the worker's fingerprintMatches the worker's face
Ties the punch to the real workerNot on its own. A login, photo or location check helps, but it is not a biometric matchNoYesYes
Conditions it handlesAnywhere phones are allowedAny hands, mounted indoors or shelteredIndoor or sheltered. Industrial-grade sensors read dirty, oily or wet fingersTouchless, so gloves stay on. Outdoor use only on rated portable or mobile clocks
Best forOffice staff and roles with company phonesFast tap and go, or as a backup clockPlant floors, warehouses, site officesHealthcare, food production, high traffic, mobile crews
One system, one place for pay rulesWhen the app and your clocks share a systemWhen the clock reports into that system. A standalone clock does notWhen the clock reports into that system. A standalone clock does notWhen the clock reports into that system. A standalone clock does not
What drives costPer-user software, runs on workers' phonesA lower-cost device, plus cards to replaceDevice cost rises with sensor gradeDevice and environment rating
WorkEasy clock to seeFor crews, the mobile time clock for job sites, a device rather than a phoneProximity smart cardIndustrial-grade fingerprintTouchless facial recognition

The one-system row is easy to skip, and it starts to matter the moment you run more than one clock or more than one site.

What is a biometric time clock

A biometric time clock confirms who is clocking in by matching the worker's face, fingerprint or palm, so the punch is tied to the person and not to a card or a phone. The three methods suit different conditions, so the sensor decides how well the clock works on your site.

  • Face. A facial read involves no hands, so gloves stay on. The touchless facial recognition time clock and the mobile time clock for job sites both use liveness detection. The touchless clock offers self-enrollment by selfie and fits healthcare, food production and high-traffic sites. The mobile clock reads through hard hats and PPE.
  • Fingerprint. Sensor grade decides which hands a fingerprint clock reads well. The smart fingerprint clock uses an optical sensor, made for clean, dry hands. The advanced and industrial-grade clocks use multispectral sensors, which read a print using several wavelengths of light so grease and dirt get in the way less. The advanced clock handles dusty or oily hands at high volume. The industrial-grade clock reads dirty, oily, wet or damaged fingers.
  • Palm. Palm recognition is on the portable biometric time clock. A palm read is touchless. The portable clock also reads faces, so one clock covers both.

Section 9 of WorkEasy's Terms & Conditions covers biometric data, so read it before you choose a biometric clock.

When a badge clock makes sense

A badge clock makes sense when speed comes first, when hands would get in the way of a sensor, or when you want a backup beside a biometric clock. A badge clock is not biometric, so it confirms the card, not the person. Decide up front whether confirming the card is enough for that site.

A badge clock, also called a proximity card clock, has no sensor to read hands, so dirty or wet hands make no difference. The proximity smart card time clock is made for the fastest tap and go. It is a fixed clock, mounted indoors or sheltered. As a backup, it gives a site a second way to clock in that does not depend on a sensor. Card reading is also available on the fingerprint clocks and the portable clock.

A card can be tapped by whoever is holding it. Buddy punching, one person tapping for another, creates inaccurate records, and a card clock on its own leaves that gap open. The gap sits in the process, not with your people.

When a phone app is enough, and when it isn't

A phone app is enough when your people work in an office, or are spread out with no shared punch point, and phones are allowed where they work. A phone app falls short where phones aren't allowed, where devices are shared, or where you need each punch matched to the person.

A phone app is a fair choice for office staff, for roles with company phones and for some field roles. There is no clock to install, and people punch wherever the work is.

A phone app confirms a login and a location. A biometric clock confirms the person in front of it. Every punch also depends on that phone being charged, on hand and signed in.

Crews on job sites have another option. The mobile time clock for job sites is a device rather than a phone app, with no wall mount needed, so it goes where the crew goes and matches the worker's face.

WorkEasy has a phone punch too, for fully distributed staff, with GPS geofencing and real-time sync, and it runs in the same system as the clocks. If you use any phone app alongside clocks, check that both report into one system.

Which clock fits your work environment

The clock that fits depends on four conditions at the punch point, which are the hands, the traffic, the installation and the connectivity. Match those first and the type of clock follows. The table shows which clock fits each kind of site best.

  • Hands. Clean and dry, dusty or oily, or dirty and wet? The sensor grade follows the hands. A face, palm or card read takes the fingerprint sensor out of the question.
  • Traffic. A busy entrance at shift change asks more of a clock than a small office does. The smart fingerprint clock is made for low traffic, and the other clocks are made for more.
  • Installation. A fixed location means a wall, power and a network drop at the punch point, not just a spot that doesn't move. A construction company's site office can have all three. The open job site beside it may have none, and what decides that site is power and mounting, not toughness.
  • Connectivity and weather. Every WorkEasy clock has Wi-Fi, so Wi-Fi can stand in for the network drop at a fixed location. With no wired network and no Wi-Fi at the punch point, the portable and mobile clocks run on 4G LTE and battery. Of the portable and mobile clocks, only the portable clock has Ethernet. For weather-exposed mounts, look at those same two clocks, which are dustproof and water resistant.
Where your people workClockWhat it offers
Job sites, outdoor and weather-exposed mountsPortable biometric time clockRugged, 4G LTE, battery, GPS, dustproof and water resistant, shock-resistant, palm recognition
Mobile crews, rotating sites, trailersMobile time clock for job sitesNo wall mount needed, 4G LTE, GPS, dustproof and water resistant, reads through hard hats and PPE
Plant floors, warehouses, site officesIndustrial-grade fingerprint time clockReads dirty, oily, wet or damaged fingers, for harsh indoor or sheltered spaces
Healthcare, food production, high trafficTouchless facial recognition time clockTouchless, 99.9% recognition accuracy, self-enrollment by selfie
Hospitality and busy mixed sitesAdvanced fingerprint time clockHandles dusty or oily hands at high volume
Clean offices and clinicsSmart fingerprint time clockA cost-effective clock for clean, dry hands
Any fixed site, or as a backupProximity smart card time clockFastest tap and go. Not biometric

A clean, low-traffic office does not need an industrial sensor, which also keeps the cost down. Every clock is on the WorkEasy time clock catalog, and the time clock lineup sheet (PDF) puts the lineup on one sheet.

If your team still runs on a punch clock and paper cards, start with the same question, where your people work, and match the clock to those conditions.

Running more than one type of clock across your sites

A company with a plant floor, a yard and a site office has different conditions at each punch point, so it is looking at more than one type of clock. The clocks can differ while the system stays the same. Every WorkEasy clock reports into one system, with one place for your pay rules.

Here is an example, written to show the idea and not drawn from a specific customer.

  • On the plant floor, where hands get oily, an industrial-grade fingerprint clock.
  • In the yard, with no wall at the punch point and weather reaching the clock, a portable biometric time clock.
  • In the site office, with a wall, power and a network drop, the same industrial-grade clock, with a proximity card clock as a backup.

A punch on the plant floor and a punch in the yard land in the same place, so nothing has to be rebuilt before payroll. Your people's hours come out right wherever they clock in, and approved hours sync to the payroll provider you already run. For a company with several locations, that makes one standard practical, with the same clock for the same conditions and your pay rules in one place.

Start with the clock and Time and Attendance. For the software side, read what a time and attendance system does, and how to choose one. Scheduling, Time Off and HR Data Management are on the same platform when you need them. Clocks are available on a flexible subscription as well as purchase, and the WorkEasy pricing page is the place to start on cost.

More than 10,000 companies use WorkEasy, and 750,000 workers clock in every day. Once you know which clocks fit your conditions, the next step is a number for your own operation. Get a quote for your sites. Tell us how many sites you run, so the quote fits your whole operation.

FAQ

Frequently asked

Short answers to the questions that come up most often.

What are biometric time clocks?

Biometric time clocks confirm who is clocking in by matching the worker's face, fingerprint or palm, so each punch is tied to the person and not to a card or a phone. Six of the seven clocks in the WorkEasy lineup are biometric, across those three methods. The seventh, the proximity card clock, is not biometric.

How much does a biometric time clock cost?

The cost of a biometric time clock depends on the sensor grade, the environment rating and the software behind it. Device cost rises with sensor grade. WorkEasy clocks are available on a flexible subscription as well as purchase. For figures on your own sites, see the pricing page or request a quote at workeasysoftware.com.

What is the best fingerprint time clock?

The best fingerprint time clock depends on the hands and the conditions. The industrial-grade clock suits dirty, oily, wet or damaged fingers in harsh indoor or sheltered spaces. The advanced clock handles dusty or oily hands at high volume. The smart fingerprint clock is a cost-effective choice for clean, dry hands at low traffic.

Do biometric clocks work with gloves?

It depends on the glove and the clock. Thin gloves such as latex or nitrile read best on the industrial-grade fingerprint clock, and to a lesser degree on the advanced clock. No WorkEasy clock reads a fingerprint through heavy work gloves. With heavy gloves or PPE, a facial clock means no gloves come off, and the mobile time clock reads through hard hats and PPE. A card tap also works with gloves on.

Can an employee refuse a biometric time clock?

The answer depends on where your company operates and on your own policy. Notice and consent are the employer's to handle, with its own counsel, and a time clock vendor can't settle that question for you. For someone who prefers not to use a biometric read, a card is a non-biometric way to clock in on the clocks that take one, including the proximity card clock, the fingerprint clocks and the portable clock.

Related

Keep reading

WorkEasy Software in the news

Don't Just TakeOur Wordfor It

Learn what the news media is saying about WorkEasy Software products and service.

FOX

WorkEasy Software recognized as a Top 25 Global Work Tech Vendor. Work Tech Awards honor best-in-class vendors.

Benzinga

WorkEasy Software powers game-changing teams with surprisingly easy technology in mission-critical areas.

The Globe and Mail

Work Tech Awards honor top vendors worldwide whose efforts exemplify what Inspiring Workplaces calls “real impact.”

Barchart

WorkEasy Software recognized as a Top 25 Global Work Tech Vendor. Work Tech Awards honor best-in-class vendors.

The Chronicle-Journal

Work Tech Awards honor top vendors worldwide whose efforts exemplify what Inspiring Workplaces calls “real impact.”

Starkville Daily News

WorkEasy Software powers game-changing teams with surprisingly easy technology in mission-critical areas.

News Channel Nebraska

WorkEasy Software powers game-changing teams with surprisingly easy technology in mission-critical areas.

10,000+ teams
750K+ workers
360M+ punches